 | #1 - Jason Matt | - | OF/P | - | Belgian Wiffles |
 | #2 - David Castle | - | UT/P | - | Ducks |
 | #3 - Dakota LaDouceur | - | OF | - | El Diablos |
 | #4 - Jason Hewlett | - | P/OF | - | King Friday |
 | #5 - Justin Hughes | - | OF/P | - | Wicked Aces |
 | #6 - Greg Voutsos | - | UT | - | Westside Warriors |
 | #1 - Don Shaw | - | P | - | Donkeys |
 | #2 - Daniel Egan | - | P, SS | - | Commandos |
 | #3 - Josh Nagorski | - | OF, RP | - | Thunder Ducks |
 | '12 All-Star Cards | ||||
 | '12 National Team Player Cards |
 | #1 - Jeff Beigas | - | OF | - | Jason Mattseals |
 | #2 - Eric Pfefferle | - | OF, SS | - | Campus Commandos |
 | #3 - Josh Roberts | - | OF | - | Git r' Done |
 | #4 - Bobby Hoppe | - | OF, RP | - | Wiffling DeLoppes |
 | #5 - Shane Myers | - | OF | - | Westside Warriors |
 | #6 - Matt Murtha | - | UT, P | - | Flying Squirrels |
 | #7 - David Buhr | - | OF | - | Belgian Wiffles |
 | #8 - Ryan Bullard | - | OF | - | Ass Kickers |
 | '11 NWLA Award Winners |
